Psalm 58 begins by confronting those who have been given authority to judge: “Do you rulers indeed speak justly? Do you judge people with equity?” David’s answer is no. Instead of using their authority to protect what is right, they devise injustice and allow violence to come from their hands.
His response is intense. David asks God to break their teeth, make them disappear like water flowing away, and cause them to vanish like a slug melting as it moves. These are difficult words to read, and they aren’t the kind of prayers most of us would feel comfortable praying.
But David’s anger is directed at people who are using power to hurt others, and he takes that anger to God. He doesn’t pretend injustice isn’t happening or soften his reaction to it. He tells God exactly what he wants to see happen to those responsible.
That doesn’t mean every desire David expresses becomes a model for how we should treat people who wrong us. But perhaps the psalm shows us that God can handle our anger at injustice, even when what comes out is uncomfortable. We can bring Him the unedited version rather than allowing anger to convince us that vengeance belongs in our own hands.
The final verse brings David back to what he believes underneath all that anger: “Surely there is a God who judges the earth.” Human judges may fail, abuse their authority, or escape accountability for a time, but they aren’t the highest authority.